How much wood does a clear cutter cut, when a clear cutter cuts the wood?

A clear cutter cuts ALL the wood, when a clear cutter cuts the wood.

Most Nova Scotians do not support this form of forestry at all. And we are slowly finding out how much it costs us.

Recently, we learned the Province is paying more to Port Hawkesbury Paper for their forestry practices, than we are making from that mill. While they paid $3.1 Million in stumpage fees to clear cut on our crown lands, the Province paid the mill, $4.4 Million for “silviculture” work. And what that silviculture work is exactly, is being kept secret right now. These imbalances and lack of transparency, add much to the lack of patience people have with regard to the clear cutting and how our crown lands are being managed, as well as the mills themselves.

There is a lot wrong with forestry in Nova Scotia, and it is exacerbated by a Natural Resources Department that fosters everything that is wrong in forestry. The bureaucracy in the department is made up of forestry industry members, who don’t seem to care to see themselves as regulators or conservationists. The practices in clear cutting are impacting our forests to the point that many experts are not certain they will ever recover. And these clear cuts are intruding on some of Nova Scotia’s most important lands and areas.

The Waverley Game Sanctuary edges our community, and is very much a part of our lifestyle and consideration every day. We experience the wildlife in our yards, we walk the trails and fish the lakes, and have been blessed and compelled to stand up for the Sanctuary as its neighbors. At the end of our road there are several land plots that belong to DNR, that wrap around the edges of the Sanctuary and are tied into the Long Lake Salmon River Wilderness Area.

Last year, we noticed quite a large volume of young trees were cut on the DNR lands, and upon further investigation we found there was quite a fair bit of this cutting done throughout these lands near our community all the way through to the Sanctuary. 33308254_2296481453747143_6087874713378357248_nI called DNR to enquire, and I was told there had been some “pre-commercial clearing”. I questioned this activity and I was told there would not be any clear cutting for a number of years. I stated there should not be any clear cutting here. I queried too if they intended to spray there, as we have an ongoing battle with government ignoring the health risks from spraying and the public opposition to it. The response was quite troubling. “No, no, we’re not ready for that, yet.” YET? There is not supposed to be any spraying on Crown Land.

There are a number of other issues in this story.

– We are in the headwaters of the Shubenacadie River Watershed Area here. I don’t think it is a wise option for these lands, to consider clear cutting them or spraying them when considering human health.
– We have a concern about the ground water, and the water table here, but also have concerns about the homes that draw from the lakes fed by these headwaters as well as the communities that receive the waters
– We are bordering on the Game Sanctuary. This is very bad news for the Sanctuary
– We are next to the wilderness area.

These lands are tied to a green belt being developed and now they want to probably clear cut and possibly spray?

It appears the practice is to consider the land as a singular body, without consideration for the adjacent lands or the impacts to other areas. These lands should be protected for their value to humans, but also due to their immediate relationship with the Game Sanctuary and Wilderness Area. This is a longer discussion, regarding habitat, pollution, water, etc, but I want to bring these forestry concerns at least to the surface. We fear our Sanctuaries are under attack in light of the damage already done to Liscombe Sanctuary. And we need to be vigilante about ensuring the Game Sanctuaries don’t quietly become marketable resource areas for DNR.

There is another issue that has me extremely troubled. Members of the public have talked for a long time about DNR employees allowing their lands to be clear cut for a mill, then it seems, sometimes they sell their lands to DNR. When I heard this, I thought how underhanded, and as can be seen in many cases, they are taking a very high return for  selling their treeless property to the government, their employer. While the purchase of lands is obviously legal, I find this particular practice involving public servants, unethical, perhaps criminal. And the valuation of these lands does not support the tax dollars used to acquire them!

As an example, please refer to Orders in Council, #2013-38, Feb. 11, 2013:

“ The Governor in Council on the report and recommendation of the Minister of Natural Resources dated January 16, 2013, and pursuant to subsection 7(a) of Chapter 114 of the Revised Statutes of Nova Scotia, 1989, the Crown Lands Act, is pleased to authorize the Minister of Natural Resources to:
(a) acquire land at Southwest Margaree, Inverness County, Nova Scotia, being identified as PID 50061340 and shaded dark grey on the map marked Schedule “A”, which is attached to and forms part of the Report and Recommendation, from Lauchie Timmons, his respective executors, heirs, trustees, administrators and approved successors and assigns for a purchase price of $116,400.00 plus any legal, appraisal or survey costs incurred by the Minister in respect of the purchase, subject to the condition that Lauchie Timmons, his respective executors, heirs, trustees, administrators and approved successors and assigns, be able to certify title to the land in a manner deemed sufficient by the Department of Justice; and
(b) execute such documents as may be necessary to achieve the purposes of this Order.”

Timmons Sale

PID 50061340

Lauchie Timmons was employed by DNRNS at the time of this sale, and still is, as can be confirmed via Public Accounts Nova Scotia, Natural Resources, Salaries. The land (291 acres) was clear cut prior to the sale and was valued at $46,600. In reviewing the valuation history, this appears to be a higher valuation given prior to the clear cut. The province paid 2-1/2 times the assessed value of the lands for barren stripped lands. Even today, those lands are only assessed at $50,400.

Being able to sell lands after clear cuts at high valuations seems to encourage such forestry practices, and it undermines the integrity of the perceived role of crown lands in Nova Scotia. Publicly, government states they are regulating cuts on crown land, but they have been insufficiently managed, and now that we see evidence that DNR is buying from and selling to private land owners and corporations to allow clear cutting, their assertions are less honourable. In fact, the words “smoke and mirrors come to mind”. We have purchased lands directly from the mills after they have been cut. The Province has designated lands “protected” after they have been clear cut. This is beyond abhorrent. The Province also gave a conglomerate of mills complete control over nearly 600,000 hectares, against the wishes of the public. The people of Nova Scotia do not want clear cuts in our forests, and we do not want to pay for them as well.

If one wanders over to the Orders in Council database, and looks at objects under Natural Resources, March 27 and 29, 2018 were big days for the Province – big spending days – when the people of Nova Scotia paid over $2 Million for lands assessed at $908,000. The various properties were purchased from pulp and lumber companies as well as private owners. Many of the lands are previous clear-cuts, ready for harvest and some are ideal water frontage and even an island. You would hope these are being purchased to develop more parkland….. The big buy up of properties is pretty much an annual occurrence, and there are sales of lands as well, and there are sales and purchases at other times during the year, but these clusters of deals in March, are done behind closed doors right before the government’s year end, and most people have no idea they happen at all. People have no idea where the money comes from to afford these deals. And the balance of value for dollar speaks to really poor negotiating skills on the governments side, in seeking value for dollars on behalf of the people.

Buying lands from staff and lumber companies who have allowed their lands to be clear cut, at inflated values, encourages the practice. They can now buy two or more pieces of land, allow those to be clear cut, and potentially sell them to the Province for higher values as well. DNR is supposed to be a regulator, and these practices do not endorse an environment of regulatory behaviour.

This entry was posted in Environment, Politics. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to How much wood does a clear cutter cut, when a clear cutter cuts the wood?

  1. bonlynmac says:

    Very disturbing. Money Laundering comes to mind? Great Investment to double your money for friends of DNR, guess what….you get Taxpayers money! Do you know what size the parcel of Timmons land represents. No knowledge of 2013 land values. Even today DNR is poorly or not managed. Just look at prime Acadian Forests being burned at Port Hawkesbury Mill, they say OOOPS!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. The article has been updated. The land parcel was 291 acres.


  3. Joel says:

    Crown does not use or fund any spraying on their land since December 2010. Also they price of 400/acre is not a bad price for cutover land, if you bought a house for the appraised value it would be a steal of a deal, ready to harvest/good plantations can be worth double that. To the point of silvicuture funding that would be a fraction of what was actually spent on the program, which is a good deal for the province. When was the last time you bought produce then had to pay to have the farmers fields plowed and replanted?


    • If the Crown does not use for fund spraying on OUR land, the DNR staffer should not have implied their was a chance they will. Houses do not sell for 250% of the assessed values. Markets especialy do not support this regarding stripped and barren land. Government could do much better than the general public if they are negotiating on our behalf. The fact that we are paying mills more to plant than they pay to cut on OUR lands, speaks to more trouble with numbers on our behalf. The cost of plowing and planting produce is built into the price for produce Joel. And a profit margin.

      And Crown land belongs to the people of Nova Scotia Joel. Every single acre.


      • Joel says:

        There are different categories for land assessment/taxation, and taxation caps. Caps limit the assessment to 10% per year max until said property is sold to a non close family member.Then you will say well it hasn’t gone up much since, well I don’t think they are into taxing crown land. That is where using the tax assessment doesn’t work for your valuation. Crop price is for the crop you bought not the next one….right? And I can’t speak to the DNR employee.


  4. DNR employees, Mills, their contractors and former mill and contractor employees who now work for and sometimes manage DNR.

    And I will speak to the fact that we are not talking about land sold in the general market. Nothing about any of this requires digging up estate laws or mixing jibber jabber about assessment caps, etc. None of that applies to these deals. We are talking about land clear cut for mills and then purchased or protected by the supposed regulator.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s